U of S | Mailing List Archive | alt-photo-process-l | Re: Pond-moonrise (was: Re: Steichen image in April's 'Vanity Fair'

Re: Pond-moonrise (was: Re: Steichen image in April's 'Vanity Fair'



On Tue, 17 Mar 2009, Katharine Thayer wrote:

... But the bottom one, the cyanotype over platinum, it seems pretty certain to me that the cyan is printed with a reversed negative. I don't know if MOMA has analyzed this print the way the Met has analyzed theirs, but since I don't know otherwise, I'm taking on faith that they know for sure that this is cyanotype over platinum and not hand-applied color over platinum. I'd be willing to bet big bucks that he simply colored in the moon (notice that he didn't think to color in a reflection of it in the water).
Fools rush in... Which is to say, it looks to me from the 3 images on Katharine's site, that the most (only?) truly beautiful one is the 3rd, that is, with the blue sky and the possibly hand-colored moon.

Do the others actually look like the small version on my old monitor from a website grab shot -- in which case, could this be a case of reputation causing value? Whatever, I'd only bid 1.9 million $ (or was it 2.9 million?) for the last one.

With again thanx to Katharine... (And what could they do to her? That jail is already full up.)

J.

http://www.pacifier.com/~kthayer/html/Steichenpond.html

As for the Flatiron, that doesn't seem quite as clearcut to me, and besides there are so many copies of that image (mostly reproductions from a copyneg made from the original gum print) that it's almost impossible to say which one we're talking about. The Met alone has five versions of it, I think, and the version they show on their website doesn't correspond by date and description to any of the ones listed in the catalog of the Stieglitz collection, so it's all pretty confusing. But would you say it's probably true of this one?

http://www.metmuseum.org/toah/hd/pict/ho_33.43.39.htm

Katharine




http://www.theartwolf.com/imagenestAW/steichen_pond.jpg
the actual $2.9 million print?