Re: dye sublimation prints

Bob_Maxey@mtn.3com.com
Thu, 19 Mar 1998 14:49:18 -0700

> > Any output by
> > a comuter is a million miles away from being archival, even with UV
> > coatings.
> > The UV coatings (I don't care what the manufacturer says) turn yellow
> > almost
> > from day one.
>
> Not true - as the best prints coming from computers at the moment emerge
> on to the very same paper that are used for other photographic prints and
> thus have exactly the same life scale.
>
> Visually they are also impossible to tell from those produced manually,
> although a skilled printer might look at some and wonder how some things
> were possible.
>
> You can have all the advantages of manipulating your work in Photoshop to
> do things that would be difficult or impossible (or very expensive) in
the
> darkroom and then get a true photo print.
>
> Being able to produce a quick proof on the Epson that is also suitable
for
> many purposes is a bonus.

Mr. Marshall, you are wrong about your reply. The comment that computer
output not being archival is correct. Regardless of the paper used to print
the output on, the fact that it is a material similar to photographic paper
means very little. It is the dyes or pigments used, the manner in which
they are applied, the way they are handled, stored or displayed also factor
into it. There is absolutely no proof that a digital image will be here
even 5 years from now. None. Nada.

As far as being able to manipulate in Photoshop, so what. This is not
necessarily a bonus. I will, however give you that being able to make a
proof is nice.

As far as your comment about digital output being virtually impossible to
distinguish from a photographic print, I can tell and have always been able
to tell. Perhaps you need more experience looking at actual prints not
digital stuff. I get the idea that you have never actually seen a well made
photographic print. Your comment about getting a true photo print....to be
a true photographic print you need to make it using photographic
technology. There is a difference between something made on photographic
paper and something that comes out of a digital printer.

RM