[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: some new imagery; feedback
"Christina Z. Anderson" wrote:
> And why hasn't he written to the list at all lately, until your
> stuff comes up for question?
I have no idea... What is that supposed to mean?
> I apologize in advance, Thor, if I am so very
> wrong on this point. Don't flame me. And why, also, when I try to "reply
> to" does the email go to you, Keith, and not the Alt Photo list where it
> belongs? Luckily I know how to cut and paste.
HuH?
I have no idea what you mean... All your e-mail has come to me via the list...
>
> Yes, Cactus Cowboy you could be a little nicer in your criticism, but
> certainly what you say bears mention: Keith, the shadows on the faces of
> your models are distracting and do not add to the image.
<snip>
> IN Afiya 04 14 you have a compositional
> "merger": even though on this list some argue about compositional rules
> being bunk, here is a prime example: the branch looks like it grows out of
> her head.
And that kind of criticism I have no argument with.. That's well in line with my
request.. Nor did I attack Cactus Cowboy's critique, in fact I explicitly
acknowledged it and said
"Your own commentary falls into the
"critique" category, as you cite specifics, etc... "
I attacked his defense of "Thor Bols' " criticism in his response to Jill, who
seemed to feel "Thor" had crossed the line..
> However, with all that said, I bet there are many from this list
> that will now, in fact, actually go to your website and give you the
> attention you need.
I wasn't asking for "attention," I was asking for honest commentary...
>
> Enough said. Now you "big boys" give it a rest, and no more threats,
> Keith, on line.
>
If something I said came off as a threat, it was NEVER so intended..
As I said in my conclusion...
"I don't think I am asking too much here...
Just a bit of respect and civility..."
I do not ask respect of my work, only of me, as a person, nothing more, nothing
less..
If a request for commentary is going to provoke an attack then there is a
problem. If attacks are tolerated, as opposed to critique, then this list
eventually becomes nothing more than a company of like-minded individuals who
compliment each other on work done in the same vein.. I hope that such is not
the case..
Keith Krebs
--
{ For the latest on the 1270/870/875DC Orange-Shift Issue }
{ Head to http://www.p-o-v-image.com/epson/ or }
{ The EPSONx7x_Printers List http://www.egroups.com/group/EPSONx7x_Printers )
{ The P.O.V. Image Service Website is still at http://www.p-o-v-image.com/ }